Boutique Hotel in Shelter Island - DeckWoman Reading by the Pool at a Shelter Island Hotel

Come visit our unique, design driven Shelter Island hotel and unearth the perfect romantic getaway near NYC. Established in 1945, Shelter Island House is flush with history and has maintained it’s original architecture adding a bold touch of chic and modern edges. Find authentic perfection at our hotel.


Amenities to Enjoy at our Shelter Island Hotel

  • Outside Pool (Open Seasonally)
  • On-Site Tavern
  • Poolside Bar with Grab n’ Go Menu
  • Outdoor Petanque Courts (lit for night-time play)
  • Gift Shop
  • Complimnetary Bicycle Rentals
  • Complimentary Beach Umbrellas, Chairs & Towels
  • Complimentary Wi-Fi all throughout the Property

Breakfast is included for all overnight guests at Shelter Island and includes

  • Coffee & Tea
  • Orange Juice
  • Assorted Fresh Baked Pastries & Croissants

Whatever the reason for your stay, discover lodging with personalized service. Find exceptional rooms and amenities plus our pool bar offering a light menu, and our new gift shop where you can find your select souvenir of your stay on Shelter Island.  Later you can dine in our on premise restaurant featuring New American Cuisine, inside and outside dining, serving dinner and weekend brunch.

One of the first hotels on Shelter Island;  Shelter Island House is set on a quiet street just a block off the infamous Sunset Beach. All the islands sights, sounds, tastes, water activities, golf, tennis, night-life, restaurants, beaches and history — are all only a short stroll away.