Shelter Island Hotel at Dusk 

Drawing inspiration from its original roots in the 1800s, Shelter Island House has been reinvented with luxurious modern beach flair and opulent accommodations. Style, distinction, warmth, and intimacy are combined with architecture that has maintained its historic details and chic elegance. You will discover casual sophistication and a chance to explore the local feel without sacrificing luxury. Our TripAdvisor #1 rated Shelter Island hotel is the right choice for those looking for top quality service and style. Find excellence in your escape.

The intimately sized hotel boasts graciously sized rooms, spa bathrooms, chic décor and local art. Guests will enjoy complimentary amenities, including an "eye opener" breakfast, Wi-Fi, Pool and Bicycles. Plus other amenities including our on-premises restaurant and bar to enhance your experience while visiting our boutique Shelter Island, NY hotel.

View All Rooms

Shelter Island Hotel tavern 

Award Winning Dining at the On-Site Tavern


Relax on the deck with morning coffee or an evening cocktail, grab a snack from our pool bar for your day at the beach and borrow bikes for a day of island exploring. Wrap the day with a dip in the pool, a game of petanque and dinner alfresco. Lastly, stop by the gift shop for your memento of your stay.  Your Shelter Island House retreat awaits you!

View The Tavern